Home     Eberle Brewing Co. 1914 Legal Troubles

        This information is from the 1914 Yearbook of the
        United States Brewers Association.
Brewery Info
(1897-1919)
AB-II#: MI-173e
Brewery Links
Eberle Main Page
Eberle Index
Main Indexes
Alphabetical Index
Location Index
Master Items Index
U-Permit Number List
Other Features
Search MBO
Links Page
Guestbook


        "In the case of the People vs. Eberle, which was decided this summer in the United States Supreme Court, the court upholds the validity of the local option or county prohibition law in Michigan.

The Eberle Brewing Co. was charged with having manufactured beer in a county, after it voted dry, in violation of the statute. Their defense was that the beer was not manufactured for sale, but to be used in causing re-fermentation of 1,600 barrels of beer which were on hand at the date of the election, with a view to making it saleable, and thereby saving themselves from loss.  The defendants were not charged with selling beer which was in their possession when the Local Option Law went into effect, but with manufacturing  beer several months after it's adoption.  The Court ruled that the fact that this beer may have been made for use in starting re-fermentation does not affect the principle involved, for the right to manufacture beer to be utilized in giving value to an unfinished brew is no more protected by the Constitution than the right to manufacture beer to utilize the brewery, and thereby preserve the value of the plane.  Liquor laws may operate to depreciate the principal value of distilleries, breweries, and other property in use and on hand when the law is passed, but it has been held in many cases that such depreciation is not the taking of property prohibited by the Constitution."


E-Mail Me!


Home
| Alpha | Location | Detroit | Items | Links | Events

 
Google


www www.mi-brew.com

Unless otherwise noted all images & content:
Copyright © 1999-2006 Michigan Breweriana On-Line - All rights reserved.
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Revised: December 30, 2006